Midnight Margaritas
There is nothing I love better than a few Midnight Margaritas so check out my super easy recipe here!
JUMP TO RECIPE
I could not think of better time to rotate this existing post back up to top. Especially with Practical Magic 2 opening this week on September 10th. So very exciting, plus it is getting to be that time of year again that I start to crave those “Midnight Margaritas” so of course I am sharing my super easy recipe with you guys. Not only is this recipe also perfect for Cinco De Mayo, but I tend to drink my Marg’s all year long! Although I have been know to add in the Mezcal lately in lieu of tequila just my own personal twist; and new specialty of the house is a Mezcal Old Fashion- my new all time favorite, stay tuned!
Since this post always reminds me of Practical Magic, another seasonal favorite. Which has now become a huge meme; when the ladies decide to have a few Midnight Margaritas, dance and talking smack around the kitchen table, which just seems like the best ladies night ever! Not to mention…..I have heard, which is common knowledge now; while filming that particular scene, the actresses really partook in those famous Margaritas for a more “authentic” film take. I say bravo ladies! So now, I feel like ladies everywhere are making Midnight Margaritas by the blender full these days in celebration of sisterhood, whether you are related or not, because a little witch resides in all of us, wink.
What makes a perfect margarita? Well I feel like that question is subjective as there are so many great variations and recipes out there, wouldn’t you agree? I mean I personally have not met a Margarita that I don’t like to be honest as they are one of my favorite drinks. Today I am just talking about a basic fresh lemon juice margarita, nothing she she or fancy foo foo, although I love those too. Just a simple clean basic Margarita, like you are on the beach Tulum or Cabo and this is what the local bartender is making for you.
To make the best margarita mix, all you really need are these three basic margarita ingredients:
- Tequila or Mezcal– I use a 100% agave Reposado Silver which is traditionally considered to be the best tequila for margaritas. However, you can use any type of tequila; or I like a smoky Mezcal will make a fun variation mixed with jalapenos and a Tarjin rim; or even Amarena Cherries and Orange Bitters- again my favorite.
- Orange Liqueur– Grand Marnier, Cointreau or Triple Sec are all delicious options you can use as an Orange Liqueur. I personally use Grand Marnier or Cointreau in my margaritas regularly.
- Fresh Lime Juice– I highly recommend juicing your own limes for the best flavor versus buying a store bought lime juice.
Here is what you need per glass:
- 1 1/2 oz 100% Agave Silver Tequila
- 1 oz Orange Liqueur (Grand Marnier, Cointreau or Triple Sec)
- 3/4 oz freshly-squeezed lime juice
- Simple syrup, to taste (optional) 1 Tbsp sugar to 2 Tbsp water dissolved
- Lime Slices
- Coarse Salt to rim the glass (optional) and over the left shoulder for luck

For A Cinco De Mayo Style Pitcher Party:
- 3 cups 100% Agave Silver Tequila
- 2 cups Orange Liqueur (Grand Marnier, Cointreau or Triple Sec)
- 1 1/2 cups freshly-squeezed lime juice
- Simple syrup, to taste (1/4 cup sugar 1/2 cup water dissolved)
- Lime Slices
- Coarse Salt to rim the glass (optional) and over the left shoulder for luck
I like to chill mine in the refrigerator as I find ice will water done the flavors too much for my taste.
Serve these up with some fresh Chip & Salsa, Tacos, or homemade Nachos for the perfect little patio fiesta, or a midnight snack! You can see more of festive my creative Cinco De Mayo Celebration Ideas here:
Cafe Ole’ Cocktails with Churro Dunkers
A Cinco de Mayo Patio Celebration
PIN ME for later and be sure to follow us on Pinterest at Jen @ JENRON DESIGNS

Definitely a recipe I’d like to try! So perfect for these long summer days in Georgia!
This sounds so good Jen!
I love the tablescape! Those chargers are really pretty!
I’d love to sip on these. Plus the table looks beautiful!
Yes I could definitely use this like, now! So tasty
First off, I love the tablescape, so pretty! I need to try making my own margaritas, thank you for the recipe!
I feel like I have to come to over for a dinner party one day, Missing out big time!! the table is stunning and those margs look to die for
These look absolutely DELISH! Love the tablesettings too.
So simple yet so good, the best kind of recipes if you ask me! Thank for the share my friend.
What fun this night must have been! Margaritas with your gal pals are the best, and nothing beats it.
Who does not love a good Margarita with friend, that is the best kind. I think it is way better than spilling the tea, spill the Tea-quila is more like it! I need to be in your your circle.
Glad to be one of the visitors on this amazing website 😀